Overcoming the “East vs. West” : Reflections on Leo Tolstoy’s Christian Ethics from the Perspective of C.S. Lewis’s Christian Apologetics



Author Information

Kyongwan Lee, University of Hallym, South Korea

Abstract

This paper aims to reflect on Leo Tolstoy's pathbreaking Christian ethics from the perspective of C.S. Lewis's more path-dependent Christian apologetics. Despite its enormous influence on modern and Christian cultures throughout the world in the late 19th and early 20th centuries, Tolstoy's Christian ethics has been criticised by a number of theological and cultural scholars in the West. C.S. Lewis, a member of the Anglican Church in the 20th century, criticised the 'blind and unconditional pacifism' that caused such a stir in British Christian and intellectual circles. This can be seen as a revolt against the fashion for Tolstoy's ideas. In The Screwtape Letters, he satirically presents diabolical strategies and tactics for dragging human souls into hell through the extreme politicisation of Christian thought, either on the right or the left. Tolstoy's pacifism belongs to the progressive wing. Furthermore, Lewis is highly critical of modern liberal theology, which claims the 'historical Jesus' and ignores the messiahship of Jesus Christ and human salvation. In this respect, Lewis is shown to be critical of Tolstoy's historical and ethical reinterpretation of Jesus Christ and the Bible. On the other hand, Lewis seems to have a link with Tolstoy in his criticism of the corruption and bureaucracy of institutionalised power. This comparative reflection on the Christian thought of Tolstoy and Lewis could help to overcome the East-West dichotomy and create a more universal Christian culture, better able to address fundamental Christian issues in theory and practice.


Paper Information

Conference: PCAH2025
Stream: Religion

The full paper is not available for this title


Virtual Presentation


Comments & Feedback

Place a comment using your LinkedIn profile

Comments

Share on activity feed

Powered by WP LinkPress

Share this Research

Posted by James Alexander Gordon