Framing Marginality: Filmmaker’s Perspectives, Romanticisation and Audience Reception in Documentaries on Indian Communities



Author Information

Prinayana Sarma, Indian Institute of Technology Guwahati, India

Abstract

Documentary films have forever been influential in representing diverse cultures and socio-economic backgrounds, including marginalised communities in India.​​ The research critically explores how the filmmaker's artistic possibilities and narrative methods shape the representation of marginalised communities within these films. It examines the romanticisation and idealisation involved when outsiders, unfamiliar with the community's struggles, make films about them and assess the acceptable level of romanticisation in sensitive portrayals. This study seeks to identify patterns leading to marginalized communities' romanticization and idealization by employing content and narrative analysis methodologies.
The study draws on existing literature on documentaries, representation, and marginalized communities to inform its theoretical framework and methodology. The research mainly analyses two documentaries, ‘Born Into Brothel' directed by British photographers, Zana Briski and Ross Kauffman and 'India Untouched' directed by Stalin K from India. Through the analysis of Indian and international documentaries, this study identifies recurring themes and visual cues that reflect cultural biases, including the influence of an Upper-Caste Gaze.
These biases often romanticize and oversimplify struggles, highlighting the need for critical awareness in addressing representation's socio-political implications, such as tokenization and appropriation. Ultimately, this research urges responsible storytelling that aligns with marginalized communities' lived realities while focusing on analyzing the representations within the films themselves.


Paper Information

Conference: ACCS2025
Stream: Media Studies

The full paper is not available for this title


Virtual Presentation


Comments & Feedback

Place a comment using your LinkedIn profile

Comments

Share on activity feed

Powered by WP LinkPress

Share this Research

Posted by James Alexander Gordon